Rev. Dr. Everett Howe
@ewhowe
Free-range mathematician. Unitarian Universalist minister. Member, American Mathematical Society Committee on Human Rights of Mathematicians. He/him Support 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️rights! #MathSky #math #maths #mathematics #UnitarianUniversalist
I really dislike these AI slop accounts that produce crap about math or history. Blocked.
Last week, a friend and I ducked into an antique mall to avoid the heat on our walk, and I found this delicate eggshell demitasse that has many many sages or immortals painted on it. Just finished some non-math obligations today, so I hope to do some math writing and editing this week…
One of the high points of my mathematical career was giving a talk in Luminy in 2014 during which your father had many questions, and after which he gave me a “thumbs up” sign. (And I *think* that was the trip on which we shared some Scotch one evening.) I hope he is well, and wish him the best.
This Zippy strip is a quarter-century old now, but I think about it a lot.
One way that I have dealt with stress during <gestures broadly> these times has been to play games on my iPad. Since January 1, 2025 my go-to game has been an old kids game (or, at least, a game suitable for kids) called Sprinkle Islands.
No coffee in hand ATM. We’re on our way to visit the younger son in Sacramento. While my wife is driving I will think about a challenge problem proposed at ANTS last week…
I used money I earned delivering newspapers (on my one-speed bicycle) to buy a Pioneer SX 780 receiver, and I can still recall the feel of the knobs and the thunk!-ey toggles…
Their next attempt. Oh so close! I feel like I am trying to housebreak a puppy.
“If these digits are not vertically aligned in your page proofs, then the page proofs are not acceptable.” That should have been clear. But maybe sending them one more diagram will help!
I don’t even remember what I sent them at this point. They may have sent me two in quick succession, because I had by now been in touch with the head of Springer Nature’s North American math publishing arm. But here was their next attempt.
They replied with the attached. You, dear reader, are human (I assume). If you had been editing my paper, and had remember my admonition (“If these digits are not vertically aligned in your page proofs, then the page proofs are not acceptable.”), would you have sent this to me?
Some things were now correct! But not everything. So I sent them two images, one showing corrections for what they had sent, and one showing what the result should look like.
What they sent back. (At least they are making it simple for me to add alt text to the images for this thread!)
Maybe they are visual learners? So I sent them this. The sentence at the end seems like something any person* could understand and check themselves before bothering me again: “If these digits are not vertically aligned in your page proofs, then the page proofs are not acceptable.” *foolish me
I responded, once again using just words, and said: “Also, Table 1 on page 22 is completely unchanged from the first page proofs, and all of its problems remain.” They sent back a third set of page proofs. The headings got moved… but not any of the misaligned numbers!
I thought I was being pretty clear in my explanation of what should be changed! Ah, foolish me. I did not understand at this point that AI was involved. Here is what they sent back. “Wait a second!” you exclaim. “That looks unchanged!”
In this first go-round, I used their (in)convenient online text-based correction system. Here are 11 of the 73 corrections that I listed.
Here is what they had in the first page proofs. Note that all of the numbers that I had carefully aligned (so that the reader can quickly understand their relative sizes) are no longer aligned.
They sent me page proofs for which I had 73 corrections. This was 24-page paper, recall. I will focus here on what they did to a table of data. Here is the table (presented here without title or caption) as I sent it to them in my original draft.
Usually, you send a draft to the publisher, they will typeset it and send you page proofs, you correct the (hopefully few and minor) mistakes, and the journal gets published. Not when Straive is on the case! (I would tag them here, but they don’t have an account. OF COURSE they are on X.)
Went to a friend’s house to celebrate her birthday. That’s Bingley in the lower right.
I edited the photo to add in some lines that help highlight some of the geometry.
Perhaps my #MathSky friends will be interested in the artwork that my wife and I bought at the Carlsbad Art Fair this morning. Made with wild oat straw collected by the biologist/artist who made the piece.
Got a new Adirondack chair for the back yard a few weeks ago. After coffee, will be sending in the final TeX files for my contribution to the AGC²T 2025 proceedings.